I was just having a discussion with my colleague about BSG and various aspects of the show and she strongly feels that they would have been better off having Laura suffering from cancer for all 4 seasons, with a much slower progress than having her get deathly ill in mid-season 2 only to be saved with Hera's stem cells and then get sick again in season 4.
I disagree with her.
Her argument (in a nutshell) is that the curing and recurrence of Laura's cancer in Seasons 2 and 3 was essentially a self-serving, indulgent use of the disease that had little correlation with reality. She feels that they could have had more impact and slowly built up to Laura dying had they let it be something that she had to struggle with for all 4 seasons.
I feel that in order to tell the stories that you did there was a need to have Laura cured part-way through. Without that you don't get the election storyline the same way (how does a woman battling terminal cancer justify running for office in an election) nor do you have the character growth of Laura wondering if she truly is the dying leader anymore (something I think they could have explored further, but then I'd be happy with an all-Laura all the time show).
I also think having a character suffering from metastasized cancer for 3+ years without treatment it far too unrealistic for me to believe, whereas my colleague thinks that they already took enough liberties with the "reality" or Laura's cancer in season 4 that they could have dealt with that (I disagree).
So, looking past
how Laura was cured (I mean, come on, being shot in the cancer by the cybrid blood was a little much) do you think Laura
should have been cured? What would the impacts on the show have been had she not been cured in Epiphanies? Would it have worked? Hell, would Mary have been willing to do that to her body and her psyche for 4 years? I doubt it.
Anyway, I'm just curious. My colleague and I have agreed to disagree on this point, so I'm interested in what the flist has to say.
Bye!
PS. Leaving this one unlocked, so feel free to share with others. I'm curious what much of the Laura-fandom thinks about this.